Short answer
Turn on Shopify’s spam protection for storefront forms first. It stops simple bots, but many post straight to Shopify and never see the form. To catch those, score every new signup the moment Shopify records it, by email domain, name pattern and repeat attempts, then tag, unsubscribe or delete the ones that are clearly bots.
Why a Shopify store gets fake signups
Bots create customer accounts to test stolen email lists, to abuse welcome discounts, or to send spam through your store’s own emails. They usually arrive in waves: dozens or hundreds of accounts in a few minutes, with gibberish names or links in the name fields and addresses at throwaway email domains.
The damage is indirect. Your customer list fills with junk, your email tool sends campaigns to dead addresses, and your sender reputation and your reports both get worse.
What Shopify gives you on its own
Shopify has built-in spam protection that can show a CAPTCHA challenge on storefront forms. Check that it is switched on under Online Store → Preferences in your admin (as the admin stood in November 2026).
That protects the form a person sees. It does not stop a bot that sends the signup request directly to Shopify without loading your page, and it does not clean up accounts that are already in your list.
What scoring adds
Shopify tells an installed app about every new customer within seconds. Brickmoat uses that to check each signup after the fact, wherever it came from, and gives it a score with the reasons shown.
- The email domain is a known throwaway provider, or cannot receive mail at all
- The name or the email looks machine-generated, or the name contains spam words or a link
- Several signups arrive from the same address or pattern in a short time
- You marked a similar signup as fake before
Steps with Brickmoat
- 1
Install and leave watch mode on
Install Brickmoat. For the first week it runs in watch mode: every new signup is scored and listed, and nothing on your store is changed.
- 2
Read the Review page
Open Review to see flagged signups with their score and reasons. Mark each one Fake or Real. Your answers update your block and allow lists.
- 3
Switch on the storefront embed
From the Dashboard, open the theme editor and switch on the Brickmoat app embed. On the Starter plan ($6.99 a month) this adds a hidden-field and timing check to signup and newsletter forms, with an optional Cloudflare Turnstile check.
- 4
Turn watch mode off
When the Review page matches what you would have decided yourself, switch watch mode off in Rules. Bot signups are then tagged and unsubscribed from marketing as they arrive.
- 5
Optional: delete automatically
On the Pro plan ($14.99 a month) you can let Brickmoat delete high-score signups by itself. It never deletes a customer who has an order.
Brickmoat has a free plan, and paid plans start with a 14-day free trial. See the plans or watch the install guide.
Limits to know about
- Scoring acts seconds after a signup exists. It does not prevent the account from being created.
- No method blocks every bot. Expect the number to drop sharply, not to reach zero.
- The free plan includes 50 signup and order checks a month; the Starter plan includes 2,000.
Related questions
Does a CAPTCHA stop fake Shopify accounts?
It stops bots that fill in the visible form. Bots that post the signup request straight to Shopify never see the CAPTCHA, which is why stores with it switched on still get waves of fake accounts.
Will blocking fake signups affect real customers?
Brickmoat starts in watch mode and changes nothing for a week, so you can check its decisions first. After that it tags and unsubscribes by default; deleting is a separate setting you turn on yourself, and customers with orders are never deleted.
How do I remove the fake accounts I already have?
Scan your customer list, review the accounts it flags, and delete them in bulk after a backup. The guide on deleting fake customer accounts covers this.